Saturday, November 21, 2026

 


The Rusted Machines, 21st Day of Hagwinter, 526 M.E. (Betelgeuse): "A whole civilization will die tonight." - Donald J. Trump

It's time to talk about the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (nerd alert!). I'm reflexively alarmed by any environmental legislation that includes the words "bipartisan," "affordability," or "jobs" in the title. You can argue that the BAJA is an infrastructure and not an environmental bill, but it's effects on environmental law and policy would be substantial. It's possibly the biggest overhaul of the U.S. environmental regulatory structure in decades.  

The Senate passed the bill this week by a vote of 62–33, and it's now on it's way to the House. They're rushing this bill though before the new Democratic Congress takes over. 

The bill's sponsors include Senators Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI) and Martin Heinrich (D-NM), so there is some justification to the "bipartisan" claim in the title, although Fox News headlined their announcement about the bill's passage, "Senate Republicans break through Washington gridlock with massive American energy, data center overhaul." You can decide whether this is Fox News trying to give Republicans credit for something, anything, in the wake of their crushing electoral defeats this month, or a peek behind the curtain that it really isn't as bipartisan as the title and Whitehouse and Heinrich's co-sponsorship suggests. 

BAJA basically makes it far easier for developers to build oil pipelines, power lines, windfarms, data centers and much more by essentially fast-tracking development over planning and review. It creates new "rights" for developers on all kinds of projects - electrical transmission, mining, and both renewable-energy and fossil-fuel production - by freezing federal review time to prescribed schedules and casting permits in stone. It also includes provisions that would make many permits irreversible and prohibit federal agencies from considering and responding to new information, such as new science and technologies, that might arise. 

I submit that any legislation that makes it harder to respond to new threats and opportunities as they arise makes the government less, not more, effective.

BAJA effectively removes the authority of courts to enforce compliance with the National Environmental Policy and National Historic Preservation Acts. It limits the courts' ability to issue injunctions to stop projects that were authorized in violation of these Acts, or from vacating permits issued in violation of them. The courts can still require new NEPA analyses, but the projects can proceed in the meanwhile, and the "developers' rights" provisions could prohibit any permit changes to reflect those new analysis.

The bill also weakens the Endangered Species Act. The bill would delegate the responsibility to ensure that projects will not jeopardize a species from the federal government to the states, most of which lack the resources and expertise to do so. The states would also face economic pressures to prioritize projects over protections as they compete with other states for new jobs and new investment. 

For pipelines and electrical transmission lines, the bill withdraws the authority to address any impacts other than for select point-source (i.e., end-of-pipe) discharges into federal waters. Pipelines and transmission line typically don't have point-source releases, and the erosion and run-off from the projects would not be considered. 

The bill gives mining developers rights to use public lands for waste disposal, road construction, and other infrastructure around mines without additional permits. It weakens the Army Corps’ protections for waters and wetlands in the permitting process for all covered projects, including pipelines and data centers. It weakens the National Historic Preservation Act, limiting the ability of Tribal nations, states, and other stakeholders to protect culturally important sites and landscapes.

Let's be clear about it: BAJA isn't creating new "rights" for developers, it's taking power away from citizens, environmental advocates, states, and tribes, and giving that power to energy sector, AI, and mining industries. It's a continuation of the long transformation this country's been going through since Citizens United that prioritizes business, corporations, and money over citizens and the environment.

To sweeten the deal, as it were, and to give it that "bipartisan" allure, the bill does include some things I can support, such as requiring data centers and other large energy users to pay for grid and transmission costs rather than shifting those expenses onto household ratepayers. It cuts red tape, which isn't a bad thing, and purportedly supports domestic manufacturing and construction. However, the shorter review times, the limits on legal challenges, and the narrow range of objections allowed to be considered would substantially weaken environmental protections, historic preservation, and Tribal consultation, as well as endanger human health and the environment.

No comments: